The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From Cooperative Children's Book Center (CCBC)

In 1860, sensitive, sheltered Silas, 12, lives with his loving, intelligent father, Martin Bird, and Mittenwool, a ghost who’s been Silas’s companion for as long as he can remember. When Silas’s father is forced at gunpoint to accompany three men looking for someone named Mac Boat, his parting instructions to Silas are to not follow. But when a horse that's run away from his father’s kidnappers shows up the next morning, Silas is sure it's a sign he should do exactly that. Accompanied by Mittenwool, Silas rides the horse, which he calls Pony, into the forest he’s feared since early childhood to find his father. Soon lost, he’s rescued by Marshal Farmer, a lawman looking for a band of counterfeiters. The marshal is reluctant to let Silas accompany him until Silas mentions the men and the name of Mac Boat, who, it turns out, is a famous counterfeiter. When the marshal is injured, he dispatches Silas to summon help from some local lawmen. Soon Silas, Sheriff Chalfont, and Deputy Beautyman are approaching the kidnapper’s cave where Silas’s father is held. The already enthralling plot is made even more intriguing as Silas discovers and unravels more than one mystery about his family’s past. But it’s the kindness and compassion of its main characters, all white, that give this story its deeper weight. Old daguerreotype and ambrotype photographs of people in the 19th century are the lead-in to chapters introducing key characters throughout this singular work. (Ages 9-14)

CCBC Choices 2022 © Cooperative Children's Book Center, Univ. of Wisconsin - Madison, 2022. Used with permission.

From Horn Book

November 1, 2021
Twelve-year-old Silas Bird lives with his father, a bootmaker and photographer, outside Boneville, Ohio, in 1860. His mother died when he was born, but he does have another companion, a ghost named Mittenwool. When three armed riders show up and haul Pa away, claiming he is the infamous counterfeiter Mac Boat, Silas is lonely and lost, but when one of the men's horses returns -- a black horse with a bone-white face -- Silas determines to go after his father. Though Silas (well-versed in the classics) tries out names for the horse -- Bucephalus, Gringolet, Perceval -- the horse remains "Pony." Their journey after Pa is not to be taken lightly, as Mittenwool warns, and it involves traversing the ancient Woods, where they are engulfed by tangled branches and whispers and moans and air thick with words and ghosts (which Silas has the ability to see). Daguerreotypes begin each chapter, lending period appeal as well as extending the thematic thread of photography and counterfeiting. It becomes a hero's journey, on which Silas feels like Telemachus, a boy in search of his lost father. Classical allusions lend depth to Palacio's elegantly written tale. Telling the story from a perspective of years later allows for philosophical considerations, as Silas realizes "the invisible threads" that have bound him to his mother from the beginning. This is Palacio's first novel that doesn't involve characters from Wonder (2012), but it involves plenty of wonder, in rich and haunting ways. An informative and personal author's note is appended. Dean Schneider

(Copyright 2021 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

From Booklist

Starred review from September 1, 2021
Grades 5-8 *Starred Review* Equal parts Western, ghost story, and mystery, Palacio's first novel outside of the Wonder universe presents the fantastical yet utterly believable tale of a 12-year-old boy's search for his kidnapped father. Silas, along with his invisible-to-others companion (Mittenwool) and a single-minded pony, journey together through a scary wood to save Silas' father from a gang of counterfeiters. Along the way, they partner with a cantankerous U.S. Marshall, who is also hot on the trail of the nefarious baddies. The soul of this rip-roaring adventure lies in the author's ability to draw significant connections and relationships among characters, between the past and the present, and with lost and displaced souls and their people. This metaphysical juxtaposition works all the way to the surprising final revelation. In addition to the writing, the amount of thought given to the physical presentation of the book is remarkable. Chapter frontispieces are daguerreotypes and ambrotypes of American Civil War-era portraits. These are juxtaposed with contemporaneous quotations and the haunting lyrics of bygone songs that set a definite mood. Attention to detail extends even to the typefaces used, capturing the period feel. The author's note is wonderfully informative, explaining processes and histories. Pony illustrates Palacio's range as an author, with this tale being distinctly different from Wonder (2012) yet sharing movingly captured central themes of heart, family, and overcoming challenges. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Wonder has become a modern classic; everyone will want to see what else Palacio can do.

COPYRIGHT(2021) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From Kirkus

August 1, 2021
A boy, accompanied by ghosts and a bald-faced pony, sets out to rescue his father. Silas Bird, 12, his father, a Scottish immigrant bootmaker and experimental photographer, and Mittenwool, a ghost only Silas can see, live near the fictional Ohio town of Boneville in 1860. One night, three armed strangers on horseback insist that Pa come do some sort of business with them. Pa promises he'll return in a week, but the next morning, when a pony one of the men was leading returns to the farm, Silas decides to ride after him, though it means braving the ancient and terrifying Woods, more ghosts, and his own fears. Palacio writes smoothly, with engaging details, but narrator Silas sometimes seems far younger than 12 and other times too adult. The presentation of the ghosts is also inconsistent: Some can see each other, others can't; Silas recognizes some as ghosts but thinks others are living people. A conversation between Silas and a White settler, following a scene in which Silas encounters the ghosts of Native people massacred by the U.S. government, plays into unfortunate tropes of Indian nations no longer existing. The eponymous Pony drives several plot points but doesn't come across as a real equine. Among other horse-related slip-ups, novice rider Silas manages a 12-hour day without either himself or the pony dropping from exhaustion. Atmospheric daguerreotypes front each chapter. All characters are White. Beautiful writing cannot compensate for weaknesses in worldbuilding. (author's note) (Historical fiction. 10-14)

COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From Publisher's Weekly

July 26, 2021
When he's struck by lightning in front of an oak treeâ€"an event that doesn't connect much with the rest of the storyâ€"Silas Bird, the introspective 12-year-old at the center of this meandering 1860 Ohio-set adventure, has the tree's image permanently imprinted on his back. Silas lives with his inventive but reclusive father, a Scottish bootmaker and photographic scientist, as well as a protective teenage ghost named Mittenwool, until three men on horseback arrive at the family's remote cabin to seize Silas's father. When the kidnappers' white-faced Arabian pony appears a few hours later, Silas is sure his father sent it, and rides off to find him, with Mittenwool reluctantly in tow. In the time-warped Woods, he meets a U.S. marshal tracking three outlaws; Silas, certain that they are the same people who took his father, joins him, en route narrating stories of his family's history and encountering ghosts whom only he can see. Though Silas's "I have made my peace with everything" perspective belies his age, Palacio's cued-white characters are simultaneously crusty and charming in their altruistic bravado, and the blend of rambling western, scientific, and paranormal elements mixed with lingering questions about Silas's father's past will appeal to many as the trio underscores how even unlikely friendships can make for strong bonds. Images made from daguerreotypes serve as chapter heads. Ages 10—up.

From Horn Book

July 1, 2021
Twelve-year-old Silas Bird lives with his father, a bootmaker and photographer, outside Boneville, Ohio, in 1860. His mother died when he was born, but he does have another companion, a ghost named Mittenwool. When three armed riders show up and haul Pa away, claiming he is the infamous counterfeiter Mac Boat, Silas is lonely and lost, but when one of the men's horses returns -- a black horse with a bone-white face -- Silas determines to go after his father. Though Silas (well-versed in the classics) tries out names for the horse -- Bucephalus, Gringolet, Perceval -- the horse remains "Pony." Their journey after Pa is not to be taken lightly, as Mittenwool warns, and it involves traversing the ancient Woods, where they are engulfed by tangled branches and whispers and moans and air thick with words and ghosts (which Silas has the ability to see). Daguerreotypes begin each chapter, lending period appeal as well as extending the thematic thread of photography and counterfeiting. It becomes a hero's journey, on which Silas feels like Telemachus, a boy in search of his lost father. Classical allusions lend depth to Palacio's elegantly written tale. Telling the story from a perspective of years later allows for philosophical considerations, as Silas realizes "the invisible threads" that have bound him to his mother from the beginning. This is Palacio's first novel that doesn't involve characters from Wonder (2012), but it involves plenty of wonder, in rich and haunting ways. An informative and personal author's note is appended.

(Copyright 2021 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

From Kirkus

In 1860, three horsemen arrive in the middle of the night, forcing Martin Bird to go with them and changing his 12-year-old son Silas's life forever. Narrator Ian M. Hawkins brings to life this atmospheric story of the power and resilience of love as he gives the large cast of characters unique voices. Pa's calm voice lives on in Silas's head, reminding him of the knowledge and skills he has. When the bald-faced pony reappears, Silas, sounding fearful but determined, mounts and, with Mittenwool, his life-long ghost companion, he follows Pa. Hawkins voices the gruff, gravelly voiced Marshall Farmer, calm Sheriff Chalfont, skeptical Deputy Beautyman, and smug Ollerenshaw with equal ease. Palacio shares her author's note in a friendly voice, providing fascinating historical context on the American frontier. N.E.M. Winner of AudioFile Earphones Award © AudioFile 2021, Portland, Maine