The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From Horn Book

July 1, 2015
Cat Sylvie wakes her boy in the wee hours. Outside, they encounter animals waiting for something. Gerstein defines characters and objects in scribbly black silhouette (with a few white accents) on mottled dark-gray paper. At last dawn breaks, light and color return, and the nocturnal wildlife retreat. The glory of daybreak, brilliant atop the sooty paper, is both comfortingly reliable and astonishing.

(Copyright 2015 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

From Horn Book

May 1, 2015
An unnamed boy and his cat, Sylvie, sneak out of the house in the middle of the night to experience the wonders of the world after dark and the following dawn. The story begins before the title page, with the boy bidding good night to Sylvie, who's perched by his bedroom window looking out at the darkening sky. Fast forward to the wee hours, when Sylvie wakes her boy and the pair traipses through the house and out into the yard. There they encounter shadows, flowers, and a passel of animals waiting for something. Working on mottled dark-gray paper, Gerstein defines characters and objects in scribbly black silhouette. Everything is dark, save the white font, some white stars, the whites of the child's eyes, and Sylvie's green eyes. At last the animals' awaited dawn breaks, light and color gradually return, and the nocturnal wildlife retreat to the shadowy shrubs flanking the yard. Establishing a standard perspective across a number of spreads, Gerstein highlights the gentle change to the environment. The glory of daybreak, especially brilliant atop the sooty paper, is both comfortingly reliable and astonishing. thom barthelmess

(Copyright 2015 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

From Publisher's Weekly

Starred review from April 20, 2015
Caldecott Medalist Gerstein (The Man Who Walked Between the Towers) lifts two everyday miracles up for celebration-the way that night transforms objects into unfamiliar forms and shadows, and the way that morning restores them to their original splendor. One morning before dawn, a black cat jumps onto the bed of a boy. "Me-out!" Sylvie tells him. "It's coming." Gerstein paints the two as black shapes on soft gray; as they creep through the house, sleeping family members and bulky pieces of furniture create graceful, abstract compositions. For Gerstein, night is not a problem to be solved. The boy wanders without anxiety, and everything unfolds with a sense of leisurely pleasure. He wonders at the starry sky ("The air is warm and sweet.... This is the night world. There are shadows everywhere") and struggles to identify familiar things. "Are those lilies and sunflowers? Where are their colors?" Now, animals begin to gather in anticipation: deer, an owl, a porcupine, rabbits. "It's coming," they murmur. What's coming is clear, but readers will find their hearts beating faster despite themselves. The sky begins to lighten, becoming a pale, milky green. A turn of the page and the sky grows brighter; the animals retreat: "This is our bedtime." Yet another page turn, and the boy greets the rising sun. "It's here!" says Sylvie. The sun casts long yellow rays, and the flowers are revealed in all their glory. It's a remarkable achievement, gratifying for the way simple pencil lines and casual strokes of color are used to create the luminous spreads. Gerstein's sure eye and patient observation of each moment of the dawn provide all the drama this narrative needs. Ages 3—6.

From Kirkus

Starred review from April 1, 2015
A young narrator says goodnight to his cat, Sylvie, who later wakes him to beckon him to an adventure in the early hours. In Gerstein's pen, ink, and acrylic art against gray paper, the night world of hallway, sleeping family, front walk, and garden is recognizable-yet everything is shadowed and quiet. When child and cat step out of the house, a stippling of bright stars across the night sky echoes the sweeping Milky Way reproduced on the endpapers. Gerstein's darkness has softness and depth: here the night world is benign, and for all its strangeness, it is simply, though possibly magically, different. The narrator hears animal voices expressing expectation ("It's almost here"); he speaks with his cat and with a porcupine on his front lawn. He hears the increasing volume of birdsong; the sky pales with light; a bear in the shadows slips away as the dawn arrives. Children lucky enough to experience a summer night in the country-or even the suburbs-without artificial light may get to experience this arrival of early morning, which has its own fanfare: at first mysterious, then spectacular, bold, bright. Gerstein's morning sky practically sings its own hymn. Everything in the young protagonist's world looks different in the daytime: the front walkway, bright roses, and sunflowers. A beautifully realized and delightful celebration of night and sunrise. (Picture book. 3-7)

From Booklist

Starred review from March 15, 2015
Preschool-G *Starred Review* Caldecott Medalist Gerstein delights and inspires readers in this meditation on the night. A sleeping boy is awakened by a meow. The cat on his bed, Sylvie, wants to go outside, even as the boy protests it's too early. But out of the dark house Is this our house? they creep, and Sylvie, who can now speak, tells the boy, It's coming. Several stunning two-page spreads executed in shades of black and charcoal and dotted by hundreds of bright stars bring the nighttime world close. Then animals step out of the shadows, making the outdoors pulse with life. By the time birds appear in the trees, the shadows are lifting, and the stars fade into the glow of morning. Glorious sunlit spreads capture not just the look of a breaking dawn but the haunting feel of watching night turn to day. Gerstein is at the top of his game here, capturing a nearly inexpressible mood. Beginning with the very darkest shades while the boy is in the house (with only the green eyes of the cat or the whites of the boy's eyes for color) makes readers look and look again, and once they are outside, the animals' stirrings will have children pointing at the darkened pages with delight. The strong yet simple message impresses: look around; there are so many wonderful things to see.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2015, American Library Association.)

From School Library Journal

Starred review from March 1, 2015

PreS-Gr 2-The shadows of a summer night sing the promise of morning to a boy and his cat as they venture out into the dark yard surrounding their house. In the introductory scene just before the title page, the redheaded boy, tucked in bed in his darkened room, addresses the black cat curled above him, gazing through the window at the dusky world. "Good-night, Sylvie." Sylvie, it soon appears, is not ready for sleep and meows insistently until the two tiptoe through the sleeping house and out into the nighttime shadows. Gerstein's roughly sketched scenes with well-chosen detail are done on gray art paper, a fine choice for these shadowy night views. The early indoor scenes are boxed against the outer page. Heading for the open door, Sylvie hints, "It's coming...hurry." The dark outside opens fully on a spread and is soft and comfortable with shadows everywhere. "Are those shadows roses? Are those lilies and sunflowers? Where are their colors?" Soon the shadows reveal a great variety of animals that begin to echo Sylvie's hint. "It's on its way...here it comes...It's almost here." Eventually a glow appears above the trees, the shadowy animals slip away, and the world gathers color, leading to a full burst of sun. Boy and cat rush into the house to announce the beautiful day. Gerstein adds a personal note about his early childhood discomfort with the outer night world and his lifelong love of sunrise. Children will surely respond to his simple scheme, beautifully crafted with spare text and with much to enjoy in the homely views of house and yard. VERDICT This is fun bedtime fare, but so much more-parents and teachers will find many possibilities for conversations about night and day.-Margaret Bush, Simmons College, Boston

Copyright 2015 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.